Nearly 20 million workers will likely be laid off or furloughed by July: Updated state numbers project further job losses due to the coronavirus

As the United States comes to terms with the scale of the coronavirus pandemic, new economic projections continue to deteriorate, indicating an increasingly devastating impact on the U.S. economy. The latest Goldman Sachs forecast predicts a 9% contraction for the first quarter of this year and a 34% contraction in the second quarter. This large drop in GDP is consistent with 19.8 million jobs lost by July, bringing unemployment rates across the country into the mid-teens.

Our estimate is much larger than was predicted even a week ago, when the forecasting implied 14 million would be furloughed or laid off. Each escalating forecast is an indication that policymakers at every level of government need to be acting immediately to curb the spread of the virus and protect the health and economic well-being of their communities.

Importantly, these latest estimates account for the recently enacted CARES Act and assume a fourth coronavirus-related federal relief bill that will ramp up state aid—a particularly effective form of stimulus. In other words, Congress must pass additional stimulus measures—especially aid to state and local governments—just to keep the losses where we are predicting them to be today. Policymakers could go one step further and use public debt to finance the wages of workers who would otherwise lose their jobs, as Britain and Denmark are doing. This would allow workers to keep their jobs, even if they are unable to work from home or their employer is closed. It would also allow some workers to save money that they could spend once the pandemic has subsided, which would help jump-start the recovery.

In the map and tables below, we have updated our estimates of predicted layoffs and furloughs by state and added a projection of the resulting unemployment rates in each state. The map in Figure A shows that California is expected to have the largest number of jobs lost, with the state losing nearly 2.3 million jobs through June. Texas, Florida, and New York have the next largest job loss numbers at 1.7 million, 1.3 million, and 1.2 million jobs lost, respectively—losses representing between 14.7 and 17.0% of total private-sector employment in these states.

Figure A

Estimated jobs lost due to coronavirus by summer 2020, by state

State Projected job loss as a share of total private-sector employment Projected job loss Implied unemployment rate, July 2020 Implied unemployment level in July assuming no change in labor force Leisure, hospitality, and retail as a share of total private-sector employment
 Alabama 15.7% 264,599 14.5%  324,318 26.1%
 Alaska 16.5% 41,284 17.8%  61,381 28.7%
 Arizona 15.7% 395,675 15.4%  556,971 26.1%
 Arkansas 15.1% 160,885 15.3%  208,684 24.1%
 California 15.4% 2,276,965 15.6%  3,036,079 24.9%
 Colorado 15.8% 369,268 14.1%  449,564 26.5%
 Connecticut 14.8% 213,973 14.8%  286,614 22.9%
 Delaware 15.8% 63,086 16.8%  82,314 26.4%
Washington D.C. 13.5% 75,412 23.4%  96,755 18.7%
 Florida 17.0% 1,330,384 15.5%  1,621,074 30.2%
 Georgia 15.5% 608,459 14.9%  769,594 25.4%
 Hawaii 19.2% 101,550 17.8%  119,383 37.3%
 Idaho 16.0% 101,145 14.0%  124,987 27.0%
 Illinois 14.7% 779,358 15.6%  998,175 22.8%
 Indiana 14.8% 404,564 15.0%  509,741 23.0%
 Iowa 15.1% 200,329 14.2%  249,590 24.1%
 Kansas 14.9% 173,468 14.7%  220,282 23.4%
 Kentucky 15.5% 251,846 16.3%  339,783 25.3%
 Louisiana 16.3% 269,477 18.0%  379,346 27.8%
 Maine 16.3% 87,172 15.7%  109,210 28.0%
 Maryland 15.3% 347,146 13.9%  454,653 24.8%
 Massachusetts 14.6% 473,058 15.1%  579,584 22.5%
 Michigan 14.9% 570,678 15.2%  751,041 23.5%
 Minnesota 14.6% 371,435 15.0%  467,546 22.3%
 Mississippi 16.8% 154,362 17.5%  222,798 29.7%
 Missouri 15.4% 378,437 15.7%  488,098 24.9%
 Montana 17.5% 68,753 16.3%  87,436 31.8%
 Nebraska 14.9% 127,103 15.1%  157,078 23.4%
 Nevada 20.1% 251,388 19.7%  307,555 40.2%
 New Hampshire 16.3% 97,024 15.0%  116,957 28.1%
 New Jersey 14.9% 536,383 15.6%  710,234 23.5%
 New Mexico 16.4% 109,430 16.2%  155,394 28.2%
 New York 14.7% 1,216,262 16.4%  1,570,495 22.6%
 North Carolina 15.8% 608,571 15.5%  791,169 26.5%
 North Dakota 15.1% 53,892 15.6%  62,927 24.2%
 Ohio 14.9% 714,752 16.4%  955,547 23.4%
 Oklahoma 15.7% 212,005 14.7%  270,402 26.0%
 Oregon 15.6% 256,851 15.5%  325,907 25.8%
 Pennsylvania 14.5% 777,550 16.6%  1,086,433 22.1%
 Rhode Island 15.3% 67,023 15.4%  85,790 24.7%
 South Carolina 16.6% 300,968 15.0%  359,582 28.8%
 South Dakota 16.1% 58,088 15.8%  73,693 27.3%
 Tennessee 15.5% 417,383 15.8%  531,869 25.5%
 Texas 15.4% 1,669,677 15.2%  2,162,152 25.1%
 Utah 15.4% 201,590 14.8%  242,044 25.1%
 Vermont 16.5% 42,746 15.0%  50,941 28.5%
 Virginia 15.3% 507,870 14.0%  625,136 24.6%
 Washington 15.6% 449,348 15.2%  601,103 25.6%
 West Virginia 16.1% 91,477 16.3%  131,158 27.3%
 Wisconsin 14.7% 377,704 15.6%  486,560 22.6%
 Wyoming 16.8% 37,149 16.3%  48,027 29.7%

Note: “Job loss” refers to job losses, layoffs, or furloughs. Map shows employment loss consistent with a Goldman Sachs March 31 forecast of GDP growth for the first half of 2020, which accounts for the expected effect of the CARES Act.

Source: Economic Policy Institute analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Employment Statistics and Local Area Unemployment Statistics data and Goldman Sachs March 31, 2020, US Economic Analyst forecast

Copy the code below to embed this chart on your website.

Nevada is expected to have the largest job losses in percentage terms (20.1%), as the state’s high concentration of retail, leisure, and hospitality jobs are likely to experience disproportionate losses. Social distancing measures are essential for stopping the spread of the coronavirus, but they have a disproportionate impact on businesses and workers in these industries, for whom teleworking is largely not possible.

Nevada will also have the highest unemployment rate (19.7%) of any state by July, while more than one in six workers are projected to be unemployed in Alaska (17.8%), Hawaii (17.8%), Mississippi (17.5%), and Delaware (16.8%).

We should note that not every one of these lost jobs would necessarily be captured by employment surveys. For example, if workers are furloughed rather than laid off, then they may still be on employer payrolls. This 19.8 million job loss number is a measure of lost labor demand that could show up as reduced hours, layoffs, a collapse in hiring, or furloughs.

Our unemployment projections simply add the projected job losses onto February 2020 unemployment levels in each state (the most recent available state-level data) and divide by the February 2020 labor force levels. (In other words, we are assuming no change in labor force levels or participation.)

These assumptions may overstate the actual change in the official unemployment rate since some workers hold multiple jobs, and it is unclear how the current circumstances will affect people’s labor force status. Under normal circumstances, people are only counted as officially unemployed if they are actively searching for work—something that is not possible, nor desirable, with social distancing measures in place. Yet they do indicate how dire the situation is likely to be for working people in every state. In the depths of the Great Recession, the highest unemployment rate any state reached was 14.6% in Michigan in June 2009.

Table 1

Estimated jobs lost due to coronavirus by summer 2020, by state

Projected job losses, layoffs, or furloughs Implied unemployment
State As a share of total private-sector employment Level Unemployment rate, July 2020 Level in July assuming no change in labor force Leisure, hospitality, and retail as a share of total private-sector employment
United States 15.4% 19,800,000 15.6%  25,587,000 25.1%
 Alabama 15.7% 264,599 14.5%  324,318 26.1%
 Alaska 16.5% 41,284 17.8%  61,381 28.7%
 Arizona 15.7% 395,675 15.4%  556,971 26.1%
 Arkansas 15.1% 160,885 15.3%  208,684 24.1%
 California 15.4% 2,276,965 15.6%  3,036,079 24.9%
 Colorado 15.8% 369,268 14.1%  449,564 26.5%
 Connecticut 14.8% 213,973 14.8%  286,614 22.9%
 Delaware 15.8% 63,086 16.8%  82,314 26.4%
Washington D.C. 13.5% 75,412 23.4%  96,755 18.7%
 Florida 17.0% 1,330,384 15.5%  1,621,074 30.2%
 Georgia 15.5% 608,459 14.9%  769,594 25.4%
 Hawaii 19.2% 101,550 17.8%  119,383 37.3%
 Idaho 16.0% 101,145 14.0%  124,987 27.0%
 Illinois 14.7% 779,358 15.6%  998,175 22.8%
 Indiana 14.8% 404,564 15.0%  509,741 23.0%
 Iowa 15.1% 200,329 14.2%  249,590 24.1%
 Kansas 14.9% 173,468 14.7%  220,282 23.4%
 Kentucky 15.5% 251,846 16.3%  339,783 25.3%
 Louisiana 16.3% 269,477 18.0%  379,346 27.8%
 Maine 16.3% 87,172 15.7%  109,210 28.0%
 Maryland 15.3% 347,146 13.9%  454,653 24.8%
 Massachusetts 14.6% 473,058 15.1%  579,584 22.5%
 Michigan 14.9% 570,678 15.2%  751,041 23.5%
 Minnesota 14.6% 371,435 15.0%  467,546 22.3%
 Mississippi 16.8% 154,362 17.5%  222,798 29.7%
 Missouri 15.4% 378,437 15.7%  488,098 24.9%
 Montana 17.5% 68,753 16.3%  87,436 31.8%
 Nebraska 14.9% 127,103 15.1%  157,078 23.4%
 Nevada 20.1% 251,388 19.7%  307,555 40.2%
 New Hampshire 16.3% 97,024 15.0%  116,957 28.1%
 New Jersey 14.9% 536,383 15.6%  710,234 23.5%
 New Mexico 16.4% 109,430 16.2%  155,394 28.2%
 New York 14.7% 1,216,262 16.4%  1,570,495 22.6%
 North Carolina 15.8% 608,571 15.5%  791,169 26.5%
 North Dakota 15.1% 53,892 15.6%  62,927 24.2%
 Ohio 14.9% 714,752 16.4%  955,547 23.4%
 Oklahoma 15.7% 212,005 14.7%  270,402 26.0%
 Oregon 15.6% 256,851 15.5%  325,907 25.8%
 Pennsylvania 14.5% 777,550 16.6%  1,086,433 22.1%
 Rhode Island 15.3% 67,023 15.4%  85,790 24.7%
 South Carolina 16.6% 300,968 15.0%  359,582 28.8%
 South Dakota 16.1% 58,088 15.8%  73,693 27.3%
 Tennessee 15.5% 417,383 15.8%  531,869 25.5%
 Texas 15.4% 1,669,677 15.2%  2,162,152 25.1%
 Utah 15.4% 201,590 14.8%  242,044 25.1%
 Vermont 16.5% 42,746 15.0%  50,941 28.5%
 Virginia 15.3% 507,870 14.0%  625,136 24.6%
 Washington 15.6% 449,348 15.2%  601,103 25.6%
 West Virginia 16.1% 91,477 16.3%  131,158 27.3%
 Wisconsin 14.7% 377,704 15.6%  486,560 22.6%
 Wyoming 16.8% 37,149 16.3%  48,027 29.7%

Source: Economic Policy Institute analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics Current Employment Statistics and Local Area Unemployment Statistics data and Goldman Sachs March 31, 2020, US Economic Analyst forecast

Copy the code below to embed this chart on your website.